Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1

Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1

  • Ellen O'Connor
  • 03/24/23

Investing in real estate has been a passion of mine for over two decades. I have developed a keen eye for identifying an under-performing asset and turning it around. I have renovated and restored 19 properties, including several in Skaneateles, NY.  My most recent project is a multi-unit historic home that was built in 1860 located in the village of Fayetteville, NY. When I purchased the property, two of the units were vacant. One unit was occupied but the rent was significantly below current market value. I saw this home renovation project as a tremendous opportunity to improve the property and lease the units to produce positive cash flow.

My plan was to renovate one unit at a time, get it rented and move on to the next. First up was Apartment #3...a 700 square foot, 1 bedroom with original wide pine plank floors, 8.5 ft. ceilings and a large front porch. Work that was done included:

  1. Updating the kitchen with new cabinets, appliances, backsplash, butcher block countertop, sink while maintaining the original open shelving. Added a stainless steel work table as an island with vintage stools.
  2. Oak hardwoods on the 1st floor and the original wide-plank pine on the 2nd floor were sanded and finished.
  3. Painted all ceilings, walls and trim.
  4. Removed old carpeting on the stairs. Painted the treads, risers and installed a new runner.
  5. New light fixtures with dimmer switches throughout. Replaced all light switches and plugs.
  6. Installed a vintage marble counter top and sink on the bathroom vanity.
  7. Installed blinds and window treatments.

In total, the restoration project took 6 weeks to complete. It rented quickly and set a rental record for a 1 bedroom apartment in Fayetteville. The lease is for 12 months at $1,400/month.

I'm delighted with the end result! Take a look at the images below to see the newly finished historic apartment. View more of my featured properties and get in touch to see how I can support your real estate renovation and investing endeavors in New York.

Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Real Estate Investing: Renovating a Historic Home Part 1
Skaneateles real estate agent Rochester real estate agent

Ellen O'Connor

About The Author

Ellen O'Connor 
Licensed Associate Broker
ABR, CLHMS, GRI, SRES
Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist
 

Ellen O’Connor is a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker in New York with more than 20 years of experience representing distinctive homes throughout Rochester, the Finger Lakes, and the greater Upstate New York region. A longtime resident of Skaneateles Lake who also lives and works with clients in Rochester, Ellen brings a nuanced understanding of both lakefront living and urban neighborhood markets to every client relationship. She is a trusted advisor to buyers and sellers who value discretion, preparation, and thoughtful guidance.

Ellen’s practice combines deep regional expertise with the global reach of Sotheby’s International Realty. She specializes in waterfront estates, village and city homes, and historic properties, guiding clients through architectural considerations, investment strategy, regulatory nuances, and design-forward presentation. Having overseen more than twenty home renovations, Ellen offers practical insight into preparing a property for market in a way that maximizes both aesthetic appeal and long-term value.

Ellen holds the CLHMS, ABR, GRI, and SRES designations and earned her Bachelor of Science degree from St. Lawrence University. She is a lifetime member of the National Association of REALTORS®. Known for her steady, strategic approach, Ellen provides a refined, highly personalized experience tailored to each client’s goals.

 

 

Work With Ellen

Ellen O'Connor offers impeccable service to real estate clients in the Central New York region, with a specialized focus on waterfront and distinctive properties.

Follow Me on Instagram