New Listing - Ithaca, NY

New Listing - Ithaca, NY

  • Ellen O'Connor
  • 10/29/24

Historic Lincoln House - A Rare Ithaca Real Estate Gem in Cayuga Heights

If you're searching for Ithaca homes for sale with historical charm and luxurious amenities, look no further than Lincoln House at 520 Cayuga Heights Road. Situated in the prestigious Ithaca neighborhood of Cayuga Heights, this distinguished property offers a rare opportunity for those seeking a timeless residence near Cornell University and Cayuga Lake waterfront property.

Originally built in 1929 by electrical engineer Paul Martyn Lincoln, Lincoln House is a unique blend of classic elegance and modern comfort. This Ithaca property listing features 6 spacious bedrooms and 6 bathrooms, making it a standout among luxury homes in Ithaca.

Exquisite Interior Design and Grand Features

As you step into Lincoln House, you're welcomed by a grand foyer with limestone floors and intricate woodwork that has been beautifully preserved. The main living spaces include a formal living room, where one of the home's four fireplaces is framed by custom built-ins and French doors that fill the room with natural light. This space, along with a stately dining room featuring a cozy gas fireplace, is perfect for gatherings both large and small.

The gourmet kitchen offers both functionality and historic charm, equipped with top-tier Subzero and Viking appliances and custom cabinetry. A butler's pantry seamlessly connects the kitchen to the dining room, a feature highly sought after in luxury homes Ithaca buyers.

Private Retreat in the Heart of Ithaca

The upper levels house six bedrooms, including a primary suite that serves as a private retreat with its own fireplace, spa-like ensuite bathroom, walk-in closet, and a cozy sitting area. The additional bedrooms are generously sized, each with its own unique character, ideal for family members or guests—perfect for those searching for homes near Cornell University or Ithaca student housing options for larger households.

The bathrooms combine original fixtures with updated amenities like heated floors, soaking tubs, and elegant tile work, providing modern luxury without sacrificing the home’s historic appeal.

Outdoor Elegance in a Prime Ithaca Neighborhood

Outside, the 1.22-acre property is beautifully landscaped with mature trees, lush gardens, and a charming stone courtyard perfect for outdoor entertaining. A three-car garage offers ample space for both vehicles and additional storage.

This Cornell area home features modern updates like central air conditioning, a slate roof, and updated mechanical systems, ensuring comfort throughout the year. A partially finished basement adds more flexible living space, whether for a recreation room, gym, or wine cellar.

Ideal Location for Convenience and Privacy

Located just minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell University, and the scenic Cayuga Lake, Lincoln House provides the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility. It’s ideal for those seeking Ithaca condos for sale, first-time homebuyers Ithaca, or seasoned buyers looking for a unique property with deep roots in Ithaca’s history.

This listing represents an exceptional opportunity to own a piece of Ithaca real estate with unmatched character and prestige. For more details or to arrange a tour, contact your trusted Ithaca real estate agent Ellen O'Connor today.

 

 

 

 

Skaneateles real estate agent Rochester real estate agent

Ellen O'Connor

About The Author

Ellen O'Connor 
Licensed Associate Broker
ABR, CLHMS, GRI, SRES
Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist
 

Ellen O’Connor is a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker in New York with more than 20 years of experience representing distinctive homes throughout Rochester, the Finger Lakes, and the greater Upstate New York region. A longtime resident of Skaneateles Lake who also lives and works with clients in Rochester, Ellen brings a nuanced understanding of both lakefront living and urban neighborhood markets to every client relationship. She is a trusted advisor to buyers and sellers who value discretion, preparation, and thoughtful guidance.

Ellen’s practice combines deep regional expertise with the global reach of Sotheby’s International Realty. She specializes in waterfront estates, village and city homes, and historic properties, guiding clients through architectural considerations, investment strategy, regulatory nuances, and design-forward presentation. Having overseen more than twenty home renovations, Ellen offers practical insight into preparing a property for market in a way that maximizes both aesthetic appeal and long-term value.

Ellen holds the CLHMS, ABR, GRI, and SRES designations and earned her Bachelor of Science degree from St. Lawrence University. She is a lifetime member of the National Association of REALTORS®. Known for her steady, strategic approach, Ellen provides a refined, highly personalized experience tailored to each client’s goals.

Ellen O’Connor is a licensed real estate broker serving the Finger Lakes and Upstate New York’s most distinctive communities.

 

 

Work With Ellen

Ellen O'Connor offers impeccable service to real estate clients in the Central New York region, with a specialized focus on waterfront and distinctive properties.

Follow Me on Instagram